This website is a comparison site, offered for use free of charge and aims to offer its users informative and helpful content. We are grateful to be of service and bring you content free of charge. In order to do this, please note that when you click links and purchase items from the brands we rank on this site, we receive a commission. Your support in purchasing through these links enables us to keep providing you with content and opinion to the best of our knowledge. Such advertising fees that we may receive is not increasing your buying price and is not affecting the content we write on each product; however along with past buyers’ preference, product details and our reviewers’ findings, such advertising fees may impact the display order and scoring of a product at the website. The content on the website is provided “as-is” without warranties or guaranties and it does not constitute an encouragement or endorsement to purchase the goods that are offered for sale. We do not include or compare all products or providers in the market. See our Terms of Use and Advertising Disclosure information.
We receive advertising fees from the brands we rank below
Crib Mattresses 2023. Reviews & Comparison of Recommended Crib Mattresses.
Choosing a mattress for a newborn involves many considerations, from meeting specific safety criteria to finding the right size and one that meets your budget. To help you make a more informed decision, reading reviews like the ones below is helpful.
We receive advertising fees from the brands we rank below. Full Advertiser Disclosure
Most recommended.
iHow We Score? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit. Illum, maxime?
Editor's Choice - Best Crib Mattress 2023
Saatva Dual-Sided Crib Mattress Review
Editor's Choice - Best Crib Mattress 2023
COMPARING OUR 5 BEST RECOMMENDED CRIB MATTRESSES
 |  |  |  | |
| Models | Saatva | newton baby | Naturepedic | my green mattress |
| Review | Read Review | Read Review | Read Review | Read Review |
| Rating | 9.8 | 9.5 | 9.4 | 8.9 |
| Material | Hybrid (Natural latex and steel coils) | Viscose & food-grade polymer | Organic cotton fill and polyethylene or coils | Cotton, wool, coconut coir, latex and coils |
| Safety Certifications | GREENGUARD Gold, Cradle to Cradle Gold, GOTS, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 | GREENGUARD Gold | GOTS, Made-Safe, UL/GREENGUARD Gold | GOTS, GOLS, OEKO-TEX, GREENGUARD Gold |
| Dimensions | 28 in. W x 52 in. L | 28 in. W x 52 in. L | 27 1/4 in. W x 51 5/8 in. L | 27 1/4 in. W x 52 in. L |
| Thickness | 8 inches | 5.5 inches | 6 inches | 6 inches |
| Firmness | Medium-Firm and Firm | Firm | Medium-Firm and Firm | Firm |
| Breathable Design | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Waterproof Cover | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Washable Cover | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| 2-Sided Infant to Toddler | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Sleep Trial | 45 days | 100 days | 30 days | 120 days |
| Warranty | Lifetime | Lifetime | Lifetime | 20 years |
| Visit Site > | Visit Site > | Visit Site > | Visit Site > |
Saatva Crib Mattress Ranking
Saatva Crib Mattress Review
Leading Features and Specs of the Saatva Crib Mattress
The top features, in our opinion, are:
- Two beds in one; one side for baby, one side for toddlers
- Organic, non-toxic materials for a healthier sleep
- Conveniently removable, water-repellant cover
- Lifetime warranty protection
It comes in one standard crib size of 28 x 52 inches. The corners are square to provide a sung fit with a crib. The mattress is 8 inches tall.
Visit Official Store
Saatva Crib Mattress Review of Materials
This Saatva mattress features premium materials and a two-sided design. It is hybrid, which means that it combines different mattress styles.
Rather than being all-innerspring or all-innerspring in its construction, the Saatva Crib Mattress combines natural latex with steel coils. What’s more, the materials are organic and non-toxic.
The cover is made of organic cotton. This is a material known for helping to keep babies safe and comfy while removing risks of allergies and infections.
As for the inside of the mattress, it features natural latex, which has a bit of bounce and pressure-free support. The latex is put through a washing process, which removes allergy-causing proteins.
Plus, latex is known for being a durable sleep material. Saatva’s website indicates that latex is likely to outlast memory foams.
Natural latex is also highly breathable. It is more breathable than polyurethane foams, as per Saatva’s website.
On the toddler side, the New Zealand wool layer at the top is naturally breathable, whisking away moisture to help regulate the baby’s temperature.
As for the coil unit in the center of the mattress, it is made of recycled steel and features 200 coils.
Construction of Saatva’s Crib Mattress
This mattress is American-made. If supporting local matters to you, this feature will be important.
The two-sided construction makes for two beds in one. It is usable on one side for the baby and then simply flip over to the other side when they become a toddler.
It is constructed to be double-firm for the baby and firm support for the toddler. The design is such that it offers comfort and support to the child at the appropriate stages of their development, explain many online reviews of the Saatva Crib Mattress.
Baby Side
On the baby’s side is a sturdy support base with breathable eucalyptus fibers. It provides a transition layer above the center coils.
Furthermore, the coil unit has double edge support to help keep the baby from the edge. It also has center-zone technology to help the baby stay at the center.
Toddler Side
At the top is a soft layer designed for great breathability. The organic New Zealand wool material is naturally breathable and is antimicrobial, also naturally resisting dust mites.
Below it is the natural latex layer for durable support and a bit of bounce. It resists mold, dust mites, and mildew.
The third layer is a support base with eucalyptus fibers that transitions between the latex and the coil unit. While it is not as firm as the baby side, it still is designed to support toddlers.
The middle coil unit is next. It is made of 200 recycled steel coils and features double edge support.
Visit Store
Pros and Any Drawbacks: A Balanced Saatva Crib Mattress Review
Along with telling you the benefits, we also explain any limitations of this crib mattress. Here are our thoughts.
Breathable Fibers
Several highly-breathable materials make up the Saatva Crib Mattress. The eucalyptus fibers are one example, as is the New Zealand wool.
They naturally enable the mattress to breathe well for better airflow. The fibers help regulate body temperature to reduce sweating rather than trapping heat.
A breathable crib mattress is a safer one as if your baby rolls on their stomach while sleeping, it enables them to breathe through the material. That reduces the suffocation risks.
Good airflow also helps prevent mold and bed mites that can grow in moisture on the mattress surface. Keeping them away can prevent infections in your sweetie.
Established Company
Saatva is well-known in the mattress industry that dates back over a decade. They are highly regarded for their lineup of quality mattresses.
This good reputation helps provide consumers peace of mind when purchasing from Saatva. It eliminates worries of the company being a fly-by-night operation.
Price
The Saatva model is in the upper price range of crib mattresses. But the price is not outrageous given the premium materials. It features very durable latex material and is longer-lasting with the flippable design. Being able to use the same mattress for your child from baby through toddler years, rather than buying a second mattress, can save many families money over time.
Also, there is a free shipping within the contiguous US is another money savings. There is a financing option available too.
With many sizes to choose from, there are options to fit a range of mattress sizes.
Check Price
Warranty
Adding to the great value is the generous Lifetime warranty. The warranty comes with the Saatva Crib Mattress, and our review includes mention of it as they are under no obligation to offer such a long policy. It shows the confidence the company has in the quality of its product.
Extra-Firm Support for Baby
The extra-firm transition layer on the baby side is crucial at this early stage of life. It can help prevent sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and other accidents during sleep.
If it is too soft, the risk is that SIDS or suffocation can occur as the baby’s head and face sinks into the mattress. The CPSC (Consumer Product Safety Commission) recommends a firm, flat mattress for infants.
Certifications
Certifications tell you a lot about a mattress and are especially important for one designed for a baby. Next, in this Saatva Crib Mattress review, let’s talk about its certifications.
Firstly, it is GREENGUARD Gold certified. That means it has been tested for more than 10,000 chemicals, making for a healthier sleep environment for the infant.
The non-toxic construction features organic cotton, natural latex, and New Zealand wool. For example, the natural latex is free of allergy-causing proteins, as per Saatva’s website.
This crib mattress is also Cradle to Cradle Gold certified. This eco-certification program scores brands by their commitment to the circular economy. The “Gold” level indicates a significant reduction in waste and dangerous chemicals, reuse of materials (such as the recycled steel), and more.
A third certification is GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard). This one requires that the crib mattress contain at least 95% organic cotton (determined by weight).
Plus, the chemical-free flame barrier is OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 certified. That means its flame barrier is certified free of toxins.
Finally, there is a Guardin® anitimicrobial treatment on the mattress. It is non-toxic and botanical.
These certifications will likely appeal to eco-conscious shoppers and are important for the child’s safety and health too. Knowing Saatva’s Crib Mattress meets the high standards to receive these well-known labels can give some parents peace of mind.
Removable, Water-Repellant Cover
Another great feature is the removable cover that is designed to repel water. It is treated with a water repellant, which makes spills a cinch to clean up.
As babies are likely to have a mess on the bed at some point, it is convenient to remove the cover to wash it. A freshly washed cover helps keep the sleep environment healthy.
The cover protects the mattress itself, which can help extend its lifespan. Plus, removing and washing the cover can provide a more thorough clean than spot-cleaning a cover that is not removable.
Free Returns for 45 Days
Saatva offers 45-day free returns for its crib mattress, which provides many nights at home to test out the mattress. Being able to return it for free if it is not the right fit for your little one may provide reassurance when making an online purchase.
Saatva Crib Mattress Review Conclusion
Saatva offers a quality crib mattress featuring healthy, non-toxic materials. The focus is on safety and comfort as the mattress meets numerous certifications and is naturally breathable.
Plus, its two-sided design with different firmness levels makes this mattress one that some families can use from infant to toddler. That makes it a good value over the long run, especially with the durable construction, removable cover, and a lifetime warranty. With so many great attributes, the Saatva Crib Mattress is one we recommend.
Newton Crib Mattress Ranking
Newton Baby Crib Mattress Review
Main Features of the Original Crib Mattress from Newton Baby
Newton Baby’s Crib Mattress is also known by the company as The Original. It is part of the Newton Baby lineup that has other crib mattresses, mattress pads, sheets, and swaddles.
The best features of the Original Crib Mattress are:
- Unique Breathe-Thru Tech for a safer, comfier sleep
- The only completely-washable crib mattress, from cover to core
- Two-stage design for both infants and toddlers
- Eco-friendly focus, made without chemicals and recyclable
Visit Official Store
It comes in a standard size of 52 inches long by 28 inches wide, with a 5.5-inch thickness. It weighs 14 pounds.
There is also a mini version, a waterproof version, and a thinner (4-inch thick) version. As earlier explained, this review focuses on the Newton Baby Original Crib Mattress.
Newton Baby Crib Mattress: Overview of Construction and Materials
The two-stage mattress is designed for use through the infant and toddler stages. We appreciate that Newton Baby has a durable design.
Let’s start with the dual-layer cover. The top layer of the cover features the company’s own Breathe-Thru Technology. We will discuss the safety and comfort benefits of this unique technology in the next section of this Newton Baby Crib Mattress review.
Below that is the natural viscose cover. It is a chemical-free approach to meeting demanding federal flammability standards.
Below that is the Wovenaire core. This layer is primarily air (90%) and the rest (10%) is a food-grade polymer. This material provides comfort and firmness to the baby and toddler, without having to flip the mattress as they age.
The mattress materials are 100% recyclable, which is impressive to us. Yes, even the Wovenaire core is totally recyclable. For someone who wants to make a purchase that benefits the environment, the Newton Baby Original is one to consider.
Newton Baby Crib Mattress Review: Pros and Any Limitations
Next, let’s discuss the pros and any potential drawbacks of the Original Crib Mattress from Newton Baby. The details may help you make a more informed buying decision.
Chemical-Free, Non-Toxic
As you may have noticed with the materials discussed above, they are non-toxic, and there are no chemicals. Those are major benefits for parents looking for a safer crib mattress free of potentially harmful chemicals and other toxins. A healthier sleep environment is something some families look for when choosing a mattress for their little one.
Does the Newton Mattress sound like a good fit for you? See what else buyers have to say
Many web reviews note the GREENGUARD Gold certification on the Newton Baby Crib Mattress as it shows the low chemical emissions. The mattress has undergone rigorous testing and meets the high standards associated with this seal to help improve indoor air quality.
Another feature that will likely appeal to eco-conscious shoppers is that Newton Baby does not use springs, latex, or glue in its design. There is no foam either. Those who also want a hypoallergenic mattress may want to give this crib mattress some serious thought.
Please note, though, that it is not organic. However, it is totally breathable.
Completely Breathable
Newton Baby uses their unique Breathe-Thru Technology to enable a 100% breathable design. The Breathe-Thru cover allows for good airflow through the cover.
Having a highly-breathable design is an important feature, in our opinion, because it provides a safer crib mattress. It can reduce the infant’s chance of suffocation, especially for those babies that roll onto their tummy while asleep.
Plus, the 100% breathable crib mattress helps prevent moisture from getting trapped in the mattress cover. That can keep the baby’s skin dry rather than sweaty, making for a more comfortable sleep. The naturally cooling properties of the Newton Baby Crib Mattress get high marks on many web reviews.
Comfort and Support
The Newton Baby Crib Mattress has a dual-layered quilted cover for extra comfort. Many online reviewers explain that the mattress surface has a soft feel.
A night of more comfortable sleep for your little one is also possible because of the breathable design of the Original mattress. With better airflow through the mattress, the baby is less likely to wake up and start crying because of getting sweaty while asleep.
Also, this mattress provides comfort and firmness for a baby and toddler with its Wovenaire core. The mattress has a firmness that some reviewers online rate at a 7 on the mattress scale (1 is super soft and 10 is very firm).
Having good support is important for little ones as their bodies are still developing. Being super comfy in bed might make for a better quality of sleep for your youngster.
Price
This crib mattress is an above-average price. Unfortunately, that means it will not fit every family’s budget.
However, the Crib Mattress from Newton Baby is worth it, as per many web reviews. Many reviewers explain that this mattress is one of the safest ones available for babies, breathable, and free of chemicals.
A payment option is available, which can make sense for some families, rather than paying one lump-sum upfront. There is free shipping too, which is a money-saver.
Plus, using the same mattress from the baby through toddler years means that the Baby Newton Original can last a long time. Rather than having to purchase a second mattress when your little one becomes a toddler, the same mattress is usable. That can save you money in the long run.
Check Price
Removable, Machine Washable Cover
The cover is removable if your sweetie makes a mess in bed. From urine to vomit, different accidents are likely to happen on the baby mattress. Being able to remove it is handy, so you can remove it to wash and put it back on dry and clean.
Rather than spot-treating the cover, simply put it in the washing machine, according to the label instructions. Once dry, return it to the mattress for a clean, hygienic sleep surface.
Unfortunately, the cover is not waterproof. However, it is water-resistant.
Multi-Award Winner
Some parents may enjoy peace of mind knowing that Newton Baby’s Original Crib Mattress has received several awards. For example, it is a Gold winner from the 2015 National Parenting Publications Awards. It also is a Mom’s Choice Award for Honoring Excellence, and it has the distinction of a Family Choice Award (2017).
Sleep Trial
A long sleep trial comes with this baby-to-toddler mattress. A 100-night home trial enables you to try out the mattress with your little one in the comfort of home.
If you decide within the 100-night period that it is not right for your baby, simply return it for a full refund. As per the Newton Baby website, this policy makes for a risk-free experience.
Lifetime Warranty
A limited lifetime warranty comes with your Newton Baby Crib Mattress. It is a generous warranty length, as per many online reviewers.
Please read the company policy to understand the complete terms and conditions. Also, Newton Baby can change their warranty at any time; we are not responsible for any discrepancies between their policies and this review.
What is Unique about the Newton Baby Crib Mattress
There are several features that set this crib mattress apart.
Wash the Entire Mattress
As per the Newton Baby Website, this crib mattress is the only one on the market that is entirely washable, from cover to core. While some crib mattresses have a washable cover, this one goes beyond that.
Its Wovenaire core is washable. That is convenient if it is a big spill that happens so that you can wash it and return it clean to the bed for a hygienic sleep environment. For details on how to clean it properly, consult the package direction or the company.
Customize the Colors
Choose from several different colors for the Original version of the Crib Mattress. It comes in white, grey, pink, or blue. We like that you can customize the mattress to suit the room or personal preference.
No Flipping
Many infant-to-toddler crib mattresses require that you flip over the mattress when your child gets to the toddler stage. However, Newton Baby has a design that does not require flipping, making it easy to keep using the mattress without worrying about exactly what age to turn it over. That is convenient.
Conclusion of the Newton Baby Crib Mattress Review
While the Original Crib Mattress from Newton Baby will not fit every household’s budget, it is a terrific value, made with recyclable, non-toxic materials. It offers firm support for both babies and toddlers, as well as 100% breathability.
What’s more, the mattress is completely washable, from cover to core. Plus, it comes with a long sleep trial and warranty. As there are many positive qualities, we recommend the Newton Baby Crib Mattress.
Visit Official Store
Naturepedic Crib Mattress Ranking
Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review
4 Best Features of the Naturepedic Crib Mattress
After careful consideration, our team agrees that the main features are:
- Non-toxic, organic materials for healthier sleep environment
- Two-stage dual-firmness for infants & toddlers
- Breathable mattress with waterproof surface
- “Wavesupport™ tech for support & durability
It is designed to fit standard cribs. The size is 27 1/4 inches by 51 5/8 inches. It also can fit toddler beds and day beds if they provide a snug fit with the mattress. If unsure, check with the manufacturer.
Visit Official Store
Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review of Materials
If you are looking for an organic crib mattress, the Naturepedic model is one to consider. It features the following natural materials.
Organic cotton comprises the outer fabric and fill, a healthier choice to synthetic fabrics and foams, explains the Naturepedic website. It is the purest form of organic cotton grown and certified in the US, and it is bought directly from USDA-certified sources, as per Naturepedic’s site.
Even the waterproof coating (so handy!) on the mattress is non-toxic. The patented low-density polyethylene (LDPE) meets food contact standards as it is made from non-GMO sugarcane without adhesives or glues.
As for the PLA layer of the mattress, it is free from harmful chemicals. PLA is a high-performance synthetic foam that comes from non-GMO sugarcane.
There are two choices for the core. There is Naturepedic’s patented Wavesupport™ or the 252 coil innerspring core. The Wavesupport™ option is a strong yet lightweight option.
Construction of the Organic Crib Mattress
This Naturepedic Crib Mattress is two-sided, with a firm side for babies and a medium-firm side for toddlers. That makes it two mattresses in one.
It has an organic cotton surface, and the surface is removable and washable. This cover has a waterproof coating on it. Below that is a firmness support layer.
Next is the organic cotton batting. At the core, your two choices are either the 262 coil innerspring or the patented Wavesupport™ core.
The Wavesupport™ core is more lightweight than the innerspring option. That can make for easier lifting.
Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review: Pros and Any Limitations
There are many great points about this organic crib mattress, as well as potential drawbacks. Here are the main points.
2-in-1 Design
The flexible design of the Naturepedic Crib Mattress enables a parent to use it both during the baby years and when the little one becomes a toddler. In this way, it is two mattresses in one.
The firmer side of the two is for the baby, while the medium-firm side is for the toddler. Simply flip over the mattress at the appropriate age for a flat, supportive sleep surface for the growing child.
Highly Breathable
The very breathable design is important to point out in this review. The Naturepedic Crib Mattress is designed to help prevent sweating while on the mattress, which helps make for a more comfortable sleep experience. That may help reduce the baby’s crying from discomfort too.
Plus, breathability is important from a safety perspective as it lowers the risks of infant suffocation if rolling onto their tummy while sleeping. Air flows well through the mattress so the baby can still breathe.
The great breathability is thanks to the three-dimensional soft cover. It enables high airflow with 360-degree air circulation.
Waterproof Coating
We appreciate that Naturepedic adds a waterproof coating to the crib mattress cover. That helps prevent any spills and liquids from seeping into the mattress.
As a result, the mattress stays dry rather than bearing wetness, which is uncomfortable and unhygienic for your baby. That helps make for a longer-lasting Naturepedic Crib Mattress, so we think it is an important point to include here.
Washable Cover
The breathable cover is removable and washable, which is great if your baby makes a mess on it. From urine to being sick, messes are sure to happen at this age.
Being able to conveniently remove the top cover to machine wash and dry it rather than spot-clean it is good news for many parents. Doing so can help keep the sleep surface fresh and clean for a healthier sleep for your little one.
Additional breathable covers are available from Naturepedic, too (sold separately). Thus, you can put a spare cover on the crib mattress immediately and wash the one you removed when you have time later.
Price
The Naturepedic price point is above-average among crib mattresses. Therefore, it will not fit every family’s budget. But the mattress is appropriately priced given that it is made of natural materials, has many safety certifications, and is designed for use with babies and toddlers.
As you just need to flip it over for a toddler, you will not have to purchase a separate mattress when your child grows to be that age. Having the same mattress for a long time is a money-saver.
Supportive
From a safety perfective, support matters, especially as your child is undergoing crucial development. The Naturepedic Crib Mattress meets the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) recommendations for firm support for a crib mattress.
At the core is either your choice of coils or a more lightweight option of the patented Wavesupport™ technology. Wavesupport™ is designed to provide better support and durability. It is designed to be firm and comfortable, made from food-grade polyethylene.
A firm mattress for a baby can help reduce the risk of SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome). The Naturepedic model has a firm side for the baby and a medium-firm side for the toddler.
It also has reinforced edges to help keep the mattress sturdy. That is great if your toddler likes to jump or the baby stands in the crib reaching for you.
No Chemicals
There are no flame retardant chemicals in this mattress. That is thanks to the natural design and elimination of very flammable synthetics like polyurethane foam.
There also are no PFCs, PVC, biocides, or other potentially harmful chemicals often found in crib mattresses, as per the Naturepedic website. If chemical safety is important to you, this feature may be one you are glad to read about here.
Several Safety Certifications
The many organic and non-toxic certifications of the Naturepedic Crib Mattress speak to it creating a healthier, safer sleep environment for little ones. It is Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified. Thus, this mattress meets the worldwide standard for sustainable and ethical textile processing of organic fibers.
It also has received UL/GREENGUARD Gold certification. That means it has undergone testing for low chemical emissions. They are also formaldehyde-free.
The Naturepedic Crib Mattress is Made Safe® certified too. That is America’s first non-toxic seal for everyday products, including those for baby. The seal means it is made with safe ingredients not known or suspected to be harmful to human health.
Visit Official Store
What Else to Tell You About the Naturepedic Crib Mattress
Some additional details to help you understand more about the Naturepedic Crib mattress are:
USA Made
The Naturepedic Crib Mattress is made in the USA. For shoppers who want to support domestic, this product is one to consider. It is made with domestic and imported fabric and components.
Warranty
The included warranty is generous, as per many web reviewers of the Naturepedic Crib Mattress. It comes with a lifetime limited warranty.
This long policy reveals that Naturepedic stands behind the quality of its product. Please note that the manufacturer can change its policies at any time, and we are not responsible for discrepancies with this review.
Returns
A 30-day money-back guarantee also comes with this crib mattress. The ability to try out the mattress at home over several weeks is great so that you can determine if it is right for your young child.
If you decide to return it within those 30 days, Naturepedic may provide a full refund (only if your order was placed directly with Naturepedic). That can provide great peace of mind for some parents.
Naturepedic Crib Mattress Review Conclusion
It is unique to find a crib mattress that is both waterproof and organic. While the price tag is higher than average for a crib mattress, the Naturepedic model is organic, non-toxic, and has a lifetime limited warranty. That can create a healthier, safer, more hygienic sleep environment for your little one.
Plus, the mattress is designed to go from infant to toddler. The flexible design means it is made to last.
It is easy to clean, too, with a removable, washable cover. As the positives outweigh any limitations, in our opinion, we recommend the Naturepedic Crib Mattress.
Visit Official Store
My Green Mattress Ranking
My Green Mattress Emily Crib Mattress Review
Emily Crib Mattress: List of the Best Features
The main features of this mattress, in our team’s opinion, are:
- Features non-toxic, organic materials for a healthier sleep
- GOLS, GOTS, OEKO-TEX & GREENGUARD Gold certified
- Hypoallergenic and naturally breathable design
It is a standard size of 27 1/4 inches wide by 52 inches long. The weight of My Green Mattress’ Emily Crib Mattress is 15 pounds, 6 ounces.
Visit Official Store
My Green Mattress Emily Crib Mattress Review of Materials
This mattress features organic cotton and wool. It is covered with 100% GOTS certified organic cotton fabric. We will discuss what mentioned certifications mean later in this review in the section on pros and any limitations.
It contains no polyurethane foams either. Instead, the organic cotton provides comfort naturally, which is good news for eco-conscious parents.
There is also a GOLS certified organic coconut coir (pad) made from organic coconut with organic Dunlop latex. This pad provides even weight distribution and is also naturally antibacterial for a healthier sleep environment.
As for the natural Dunlop latex, it is sustainably sourced from the rubber tree. At the core is a 150 coil innerspring.
The thickness of the coils is 13.5 gauge. It has a supportive edge, too, explains the My Green Mattress website.
As you can see, natural materials make up the Emily Organic Crib Mattress. Thus, parents looking to make a healthier, eco-friendly purchase might put this mattress high on their list.
What about the Construction?
The quilted organic cover and all-natural coconut coir form the top of the mattress. Rather than using traditional foams, a heavy batting of organic cotton provides comfort for the baby.
At the core is a 150 coil innerspring. It is heavy-duty, designed for great durability.
The design is two-sided, which means that it is the same on each side. That makes it flippable, providing a longer lifespan. Both sides are the same composition and firmness.
Regarding firmness, the Emily Crib Mattress is firm, as per ratings in many online reviews. A firm crib mattress can help reduce suffocation.
Pros and Any Limitations of the Emily Organic Crib Mattress
There are many great features, including the use of non-toxic, natural materials, as discussed already. While there are also some limitations, we feel the positives outweigh them.
Safety
The wool material in the Emily Organic Crib Mattress is a natural flame barrier. Rather than using chemicals, which is a concern for many parents, My Green Mattress takes a natural approach.
As a result, there is little-to-no off-gassing, which can aggravate those who have scent sensitivities. Also, you can feel good that you are taking steps to improve the air quality by investing in this Emily mattress.
Another safety feature is the excellent breathability of the mattress. The coconut coir (pad) encourages good airflow, which means that if the baby rolls onto their stomach while asleep, they can still breathe through the mattress. That may reduce the risk of infant suffocation.
This crib mattress is designed to meet the CPSC’s health and safety requirements, explains the My Green Mattress website. CPSC is the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Knowing the high standards met, and the certifications (see below), can help some parents rest easier at night.
Certifications
We are impressed by the many certifications in My Green Mattress’ Emily Crib Mattress. It is GREENGUARD Gold certified, for example. That means a third-party lab has tested and approved it for indoor air quality and low chemical emissions.
Also, the cotton and wool are both GOTS certified organic. GOTS stands for Global Organic Textile Standard. This seal tells you the mattress does not contain volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are chemicals used during the manufacturing process, such as formaldehyde, chemical flame retardants, and heavy metals. The GOTS certification can reassure some parents who worry about the baby inhaling chemicals.
Plus, the Dunlop latex in the mattress has the Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS) seal, meaning it is made of the highest amount of natural latex possible. Natural latex deters dust mites that might otherwise cause allergens.
The latex in the Emily Organic Crib Mattress is also OEKO-TEX certified. To meet this standard, testing was done to screen the latex for harmful substances.
With all these well-known certifications, the Emily model for infants is one to consider. That is especially true if you are looking for a crib mattress that features natural or organic materials.
Price
My Green Mattress Emily Crib Mattress is reasonably priced, and many reviews online agree with us. While the use of organic materials usually bumps up the price, this one is still affordable.
There is free standard shipping, too, if you live in the contiguous United States. The free shipping feature can save your family money. Orders for Alaska and Hawaii have a small shipping fee.
Check Price
Flippable Design
However, it is not an infant-to-toddler design, meaning that it is not meant to be usable through the toddler years. It is specifically for the baby stage.
But you can flip it as it is upholstered on two sides. Each side is identical. This feature is handy if a big mess happens on one side. You can simply flip it over for a drier other side.
Being able to flip the crib mattress is also helpful for breaking it in evenly. On their website, My Green Mattress suggests flipping it once a month for the first three months and then alternate flipping and rotating once pers season so that no body impression form.
We do wish it was waterproof, though, given that babies tend to have accidents in bed. However, it naturally resists mold, mildew, and dust mites.
A waterproof organic cotton protector is sold separately. The crib size protector is machine washable.
Hypoallergenic
Wool is a naturally hypoallergenic material. Thus, it acts as a barrier in My Green Mattress’ Emily Crib Mattress to combat mold, mildew, and dust mites. That can help make for a more hygienic, healthier sleeping environment for babies.
The organic cotton in the mattress can also reduce the risk of allergies. Thus, you are cutting down the number of allergens your baby is exposed to while asleep. If your little one is sensitive to allergens or you, as a parent, are concerned about this possibility, a hypoallergenic crib mattress can provide peace of mind.
Comfort
It features natural materials that are very comfortable. For example, the quilted organic cotton cover is soft and comfy, as per several web reviews.
Along with the breathable design being a safety feature, it also helps to promote comfort. With good airflow, the Emily Crib Mattress helps the little one stay dry and cool while asleep. That is because the mattress is less likely to trap heat and lead to a sweaty back. Sweating can interrupt a baby’s sleep and cause them to cry.
Visit Official Store
Emily Organic Crib Mattress: Other Important Things to Know
There are a few more things to tell you about the My Green Mattress model for babies. The additional information can help you make a more informed decision.
Warranty
A 20-year warranty comes with the Emily Organic Crib Mattress, which is a very respectable length of time, in our opinion. Find complete details about the protection this policy provides on the website or contact My Green Mattress directly.
Please note too that the warranty can change at any time. We are not responsible for discrepancies between any of the company policies and our review.
Home Trial
A 120-night sleep trial is included too. This period enables you to try out the crib mattress at home with the option to return or exchange it within those 120 nights if you are not completely satisfied.
A policy like this one is great to have because it provides the reassurance that you can try out the mattress at home for several months to determine if it is right for your baby. We encourage you to read the sleep trial policy in full whenever shopping for a mattress online.
Made in the USA
The Emily Organic Crib Mattress is American-made. If you are interested in products made domestically, this feature will be important to you.
My Green Mattress Emily Crib Mattress Review Conclusion
This crib mattress features top-quality, natural materials. It is likely to appeal to eco-conscious shoppers looking for a certified organic mattress.
While it is not waterproof, it is affordable and has many features designed for a healthy, safer sleep environment for baby. For example, it is highly breathable and has firm support.
Plus, there are several certifications, including GOLS, GOTS, and GREENGUARD Gold. If a non-toxic, eco-friendly mattress for a baby is important to you, consider My Green Mattress’ Emily Crib Mattress.
Visit Official Store
The Top 5 Mattresses Online
Saatva Crib Mattress
Read Review
Newton
Read Review 
Naturepedic
Read Review 
My Green Mattress
Read Review
Disclosure: We are happy to provide you with free content to help you find the best crib mattress for your baby. We recognize the importance of this purchase and the role of reviews in narrowing down the options. To help us continue to provide this content, we receive a small commission if you purchase through a link in any post or page to one of our partners’ websites. This process does not increase the price or affect our ratings or reviews. Providing accurate info, to the best of our knowledge, is vital to us.
How to Select a Crib Mattress
While it might seem easy to pick a crib mattress, the reality is that there is a lot to think about here. This is where your baby will sleep for countless hours, so finding one that is safer and is part of a healthier sleep environment is important. Starting their sleep routine on the right footing matters! While a beautifully decorated nursery is nice, ultimately the crib mattress is the vital item.
Safety and the Best of the Crib Mattress Choices
Safety is the focus of the crib mattress shopping experience. The mattress is as important as the frame because it must fit securely inside the crib without gaps that pose a risk to your baby.
All crib mattresses in the United States must meet certain safety standards, as set by the CPSC (Consumer Product Safety Commission) and the American Society for Testing and Materials. These organizations provide regulations so parents can find mattresses that meet basic safety levels.
A new, certified crib mattress is often ideal. That means staying away from older cribs, hand-me-down models, and air mattresses, all of which may be unsafe for babies.
Crib mattresses made of safe materials typically come in three categories. They can be foam, innerspring, or organic.
Foam is soft and light, but parents must be aware that overly-soft foam can leave the baby vulnerable to life-threatening health problems. Organic mattresses are often free of chemicals during production but watch your child to ensure they do not have an allergic reaction to the material.
As for innerspring crib mattresses, some of the best ones are a higher price point than foam or organic. Thus, they will not fit every family’s budget. However, they can provide a firm, stable sleeping surface.
Top Considerations When Shopping for a New Crib Mattress
While not every parent has the same set of features that they look for in the best crib mattresses, certain qualities that are common considerations. They are:
Safety – Even if a mattress fits within a crib, avoid using it unless it is a specifically designed crib mattress as it may pose a safety risk to your baby. See the previous section for additional safety considerations.
Certifications – Looking for certifications on the product of interest will tell you more about it. For example, the GREENGUARD Gold certification shows the product is certified for low chemical emissions and more.
Type – Choose from foam, organic, or innerspring as safe materials for the new crib mattress. Each one has benefits and drawbacks, as discussed earlier.
Ventilation – A well-ventilated crib mattress helps cut down on smells if your baby has a mess in bed. Most modern mattresses have small holes that allow air to flow through them, and some are designed to be more breathable.
Size – A mattress must fit the frame snuggly to avoid the baby’s legs or arms getting caught between it and the crib itself, potentially leading to injury or even long-term damage. If you can put two fingers between the mattress edge and the crib, the mattress is not the correct size.
Comfort – A firmer mattress is usually the best as a soft one that conforms to the baby’s head can increase risks of suffocation or SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome). Plus, a firm mattress may provide much-needed support for the baby’s growing bones and spine.
Budget – A new crib mattress can range widely from around $100 to $400 and up. While there are quality options available at almost any budget, it is wise to do your research to know which ones have what is important to you. Our best crib mattress reviews aim to save you time by providing you with the relevant details about each model.
Quality – Look for quality when shopping for a new crib mattress to find the best one for you. Our reviews include information about types of materials and construction to help you evaluate its quality.
Non-Toxic – If your budget allows, consider a crib mattress free of toxic chemicals. Feel good about creating a safe, healthy sleep environment for the start of your child’s life.
Mattress Depth and Weight – Equal weight distribution matters, as does ensuring the mattress is the appropriate depth and weight for the crib.
Waterproof Covering – Accidents will happen with babies around, and so a waterproof cover for the mattress might be important to you. A good waterproof mattress prevents spills and messes from seeping in and keep the baby’s environment dry and healthy.
Reversible – If you want to have the mattress for a long time, consider a reversible one. Some of the best crib mattresses are usable on one side for a baby and flip over to use later. The package typically tells you what side to use when.
What Else to Consider When Shopping Online
Return Policy – We encourage you to check the return policy for any product you purchase online. This ensures that you can return it within a certain time for a full refund if you are not completely satisfied.
Warranty – Always read the warranty in full before hitting the buy button. That way, you know what the policy includes and what it might exclude.
American Made – If buying USA-made products is important to you, this feature will be something you keep in mind when looking for a new crib mattress.
The Best Crib Mattress Reviews to Help You Find the Right One
With so many different models on the market, our reviews of the best crib mattresses online help you narrow down the options by providing detailed, relevant information. We only review the leading ones and work with trusted partners, so you can feel more confident while shopping for such an important item.
Reading reviews of each crib mattress is a great way to decide which one has the features you want and see how the models differ from one another. The information will help you determine which one to bring into your home for your precious child.
Our top choices for latex mattresses are:
COMPARING OUR 5 BEST RECOMMENDED CRIB MATTRESSES
| | | | |
| Models | Saatva | newton baby | Naturepedic | my green mattress |
| Review | Read Review | Read Review | Read Review | Read Review |
| Rating | 9.8 | 9.5 | 9.4 | 8.9 |
| Material | Hybrid (Natural latex and steel coils) | Viscose & food-grade polymer | Organic cotton fill and polyethylene or coils | Cotton, wool, coconut coir, latex and coils |
| Safety Certifications | GREENGUARD Gold, Cradle to Cradle Gold, GOTS, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 | GREENGUARD Gold | GOTS, Made-Safe, UL/GREENGUARD Gold | GOTS, GOLS, OEKO-TEX, GREENGUARD Gold |
| Dimensions | 28 in. W x 52 in. L | 28 in. W x 52 in. L | 27 1/4 in. W x 51 5/8 in. L | 27 1/4 in. W x 52 in. L |
| Thickness | 8 inches | 5.5 inches | 6 inches | 6 inches |
| Firmness | Medium-Firm and Firm | Firm | Medium-Firm and Firm | Firm |
| Breathable Design | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Waterproof Cover | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Washable Cover | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| 2-Sided Infant to Toddler | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Sleep Trial | 45 days | 100 days | 30 days | 120 days |
| Warranty | Lifetime | Lifetime | Lifetime | 20 years |
| Visit Site > | Visit Site > | Visit Site > | Visit Site > |
Disclosure: We are grateful to be of service and bring you content free of charge. In order to do this, please note that when you click links and purchase items, we earn from qualified purchases from the brands reviewed on this site. We do not compare all providers in the market. The compensation we receive is not affecting the content we write on each product; however along with past buyers preference and compensation rate, it may impact the display order and scoring of a product at the website. Your support in purchasing through these links enables us to keep providing you with free content. Your buying price is not changing whether we are entitled for an affiliate compensation or not. Thank you!
How to Select a Crib Mattress
While it might seem easy to pick a crib mattress, the reality is that there is a lot to think about here. This is where your baby will sleep for countless hours, so finding one that is safer and is part of a healthier sleep environment is important. Starting their sleep routine on the right footing matters! While a beautifully decorated nursery is nice, ultimately the crib mattress is the vital item.
Safety and the Best of the Crib Mattress Choices
Safety is the focus of the crib mattress shopping experience. The mattress is as important as the frame because it must fit securely inside the crib without gaps that pose a risk to your baby.
All crib mattresses in the United States must meet certain safety standards, as set by the CPSC (Consumer Product Safety Commission) and the American Society for Testing and Materials. These organizations provide regulations so parents can find mattresses that meet basic safety levels.
A new, certified crib mattress is often ideal. That means staying away from older cribs, hand-me-down models, and air mattresses, all of which may be unsafe for babies.
Crib mattresses made of safe materials typically come in three categories. They can be foam, innerspring, or organic.
Foam is soft and light, but parents must be aware that overly-soft foam can leave the baby vulnerable to life-threatening health problems. Organic mattresses are often free of chemicals during production but watch your child to ensure they do not have an allergic reaction to the material.
As for innerspring crib mattresses, some of the best ones are a higher price point than foam or organic. Thus, they will not fit every family’s budget. However, they can provide a firm, stable sleeping surface.
Top Considerations When Shopping for a New Crib Mattress
While not every parent has the same set of features that they look for in the best crib mattresses, certain qualities that are common considerations. They are:
Safety – Even if a mattress fits within a crib, avoid using it unless it is a specifically designed crib mattress as it may pose a safety risk to your baby. See the previous section for additional safety considerations.
Certifications – Looking for certifications on the product of interest will tell you more about it. For example, the GREENGUARD Gold certification shows the product is certified for low chemical emissions and more.
Type – Choose from foam, organic, or innerspring as safe materials for the new crib mattress. Each one has benefits and drawbacks, as discussed earlier.
Ventilation – A well-ventilated crib mattress helps cut down on smells if your baby has a mess in bed. Most modern mattresses have small holes that allow air to flow through them, and some are designed to be more breathable.
Size – A mattress must fit the frame snuggly to avoid the baby’s legs or arms getting caught between it and the crib itself, potentially leading to injury or even long-term damage. If you can put two fingers between the mattress edge and the crib, the mattress is not the correct size.
Comfort – A firmer mattress is usually the best as a soft one that conforms to the baby’s head can increase risks of suffocation or SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome). Plus, a firm mattress may provide much-needed support for the baby’s growing bones and spine.
Budget – A new crib mattress can range widely from around $100 to $400 and up. While there are quality options available at almost any budget, it is wise to do your research to know which ones have what is important to you. Our best crib mattress reviews aim to save you time by providing you with the relevant details about each model.
Quality – Look for quality when shopping for a new crib mattress to find the best one for you. Our reviews include information about types of materials and construction to help you evaluate its quality.
Non-Toxic – If your budget allows, consider a crib mattress free of toxic chemicals. Feel good about creating a safe, healthy sleep environment for the start of your child’s life.
Mattress Depth and Weight – Equal weight distribution matters, as does ensuring the mattress is the appropriate depth and weight for the crib.
Waterproof Covering – Accidents will happen with babies around, and so a waterproof cover for the mattress might be important to you. A good waterproof mattress prevents spills and messes from seeping in and keep the baby’s environment dry and healthy.
Reversible – If you want to have the mattress for a long time, consider a reversible one. Some of the best crib mattresses are usable on one side for a baby and flip over to use later. The package typically tells you what side to use when.
What Else to Consider When Shopping Online
Return Policy – We encourage you to check the return policy for any product you purchase online. This ensures that you can return it within a certain time for a full refund if you are not completely satisfied.
Warranty – Always read the warranty in full before hitting the buy button. That way, you know what the policy includes and what it might exclude.
American Made – If buying USA-made products is important to you, this feature will be something you keep in mind when looking for a new crib mattress.
The Best Crib Mattress Reviews to Help You Find the Right One
With so many different models on the market, our reviews of the best crib mattresses online help you narrow down the options by providing detailed, relevant information. We only review the leading ones and work with trusted partners, so you can feel more confident while shopping for such an important item.
Reading reviews of each crib mattress is a great way to decide which one has the features you want and see how the models differ from one another. The information will help you determine which one to bring into your home for your precious child.
Our top choices for latex mattresses are: